“The Treasure in Our Hands” – The 25th Sunday after Pentecost, Proper 28A

“The Treasure in Our Hands” – The 25th Sunday after Pentecost, Proper 28A

The 25th Sunday after Pentecost, Proper 28A   
November 15, 2026                                                                       

Judges 4:1-7; Psalm 123; 1 Thessalonians 5:1-11; Matthew 25:14-30

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

“The Treasure in OUr Hands”

The Rev. Kathleen Murray, Rector                                                    

Most churches keep asking a good question: How do we live as the Church out in the world as well as when we gather for worship?

This parable comes near the end of Jesus’ teaching, just days before his arrest. His disciples want to know when the end will come. He doesn’t give them a date. He tells them how to live in the meantime.[1]

A wealthy man is going away. Before he leaves, he calls in three slaves and entrusts his property to them: five talents to the first, two to the second, and one to the third.

We should pause over that word, “slave.” The King James Version says “servant”; the New Revised Standard Version translates the Greek more directly as “slave.” In the Roman world, human beings could be bought, sold, inherited, and treated as property. Some were entrusted with considerable responsibility, as enslaved people also were in America. That did not make them free. The differences between the two systems do not make ancient slavery a benign arrangement.[2]

We hear “talent” and think of piano lessons. That’s a fine sermon, but it isn’t this parable. In Jesus’ day, a talent was a substantial sum of money, something like fifteen or twenty years of a laborer’s wages.[3] Even the slave who receives only one is holding a fortune.

And it is the master’s own fortune, entrusted to their care. Two slaves go out and trade with what they have received, and they double it. The third digs a hole and buries his master’s money. When the master returns, the slave says he knew him to be harsh. Then comes the heart of his explanation: “I was afraid.”[4]

I was afraid.

An enslaved man could have very good reasons to be afraid. The ending of this story gives us little reason to dismiss his fear. Burying money was a recognized way of protecting it, one that later rabbinic teaching would describe as proper care for money entrusted to someone.[5] This slave could return exactly what he had received, with not a penny missing.

Yet in Jesus’ story, preserving it is not enough. The ending is harsh. The master calls the slave wicked and lazy, takes the talent away, and orders him thrown into the outer darkness.[6] I don’t think we do ourselves any favors by pretending those are easy words. They give real weight to the question of what we do with what has been entrusted to us.

But judgment is not the only thing the master speaks. To each of the first two slaves, he says, “Enter into the joy of your master.”[7] They began with different amounts, but they receive the same welcome. The parable suggested that the first two slaves trusted, while the third did not.

Our circumstances are very different from those of the slaves in this story. But we can still ask whether fear has narrowed what we are willing to do with what has been entrusted to us. Many of us have spent our lives being careful, and we have good reasons for it. We know that resources are limited and that somebody has to take responsibility for what happens next. We are not especially likely to squander God’s gifts on riotous living.[8][8]

Our temptation may be closer to the hole in the ground. We can become so concerned with protecting what we have that we lose sight of what it is for. Careful stewardship matters, but it has to serve a purpose beyond preservation. A church can keep everything in good order and still become reluctant to let its life reach beyond the people who already know their way through the door.

Matthew tells us that the slave “hid” his master’s money. Earlier in this Gospel, Jesus uses a form of that same word when he says that a city built on a hill cannot be hidden. “You are the light of the world,” he tells his disciples. Nobody lights a lamp and puts it under a basket.

The important part of that: the light is meant to illuminate something. The treasure is meant to be put to use.[9]

That brings us back to our question about being the Church in the world. What has God put into our hands, and what might it mean to use it?

There is another story about talents earlier in Matthew. A slave owes a king ten thousand of them, an impossible debt, more than he could repay in many lifetimes. The king forgives the debt. Then the slave goes out and refuses to forgive someone who owes him a comparatively small amount. When the king hears about it, he calls the slave back and asks, “Should you not have had mercy on your fellow slave, as I had mercy on you?”[10]

That story helps me hear this one. Among the treasures God has put into our hands is mercy. We asked for it in the psalm this morning: “Have mercy upon us, O Lord, have mercy.”[11] Every one of us here lives on that mercy, and receiving it invites us to change how we live with others.

Emmanuel’s Table and our monthly potlucks bring us into relationships with people whose lives we might otherwise know very little about. The same is true when we open our churches to Al-Anon, AA, Scouts, and the Garden Club, and when we serve cookies and cocoa at Christmas parades. We have something to give, and we have something to learn from the neighbors we meet.

The first slave gets started “at once.”[12] Apparently, he manages to begin without commissioning a feasibility study. I say that as someone who spends a good deal of time in church meetings and loves a good study group. The learning matters. In EfM and our book study, we wrestle with what faith asks of us and let what we learn shape what we do when the session ends.

Sometimes the next step may be as ordinary as a conversation we have been avoiding. Perhaps two people who disagree about nearly everything could have lunch and make a serious effort to hear one another. Lunch will not settle every disagreement, but it can give us a place to practice speaking honestly and listening without contempt. That would be a useful practice to carry to the Thanksgiving table, which is coming, ready or not.

We can ask where fear has narrowed our choices, and where the mercy we have received might lead us next.

At a recent Planning for Wellness conference sponsored by the Church Pension Group, I chose a sticker that now sits on the back of my iPhone case: “Life begins where fear ends.” I don’t expect a sticker to make me fearless, but it reminds me that fear must not make our decisions. We can feel afraid and still take the next step, trusting that God has given us something worth sharing and will be with us as we do.

Pastor John Buchanan describes this parable as an invitation to the adventure of faith. Jesus invites us to live as fully as possible by investing our lives in following him, willing to take risks and accept responsibilities beyond what is familiar. It is, as Buchanan puts it, “the high-risk venture of being a disciple of Jesus Christ.”[13]

In a few minutes, you will come forward to this table. You will hold out your hands, open and empty, and the Body of Christ will be placed in them. Christ gives himself to us and draws us into his life. We come as people who need mercy, and we receive the one whose mercy we are called to share.

Then the dismissal will send us out: “Go in peace to love and serve the Lord.” That sending belongs with the command near the end of Matthew’s Gospel to go and make disciples.[14]

We have been entrusted with a fortune, and Christ goes with us as we put it to work. May we enter that joy as we carry the treasure of his mercy from this table into the lives of our neighbors.

Amen.

[1] Matthew 24:3, 36; 25:14–30; 26:1–2., New Revised Standard Updated Edition (“NRSVUE”).

[2] Cf. Jennifer A. Glancy, Slavery in Early Christianity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002), introduction and chapters 1–2. For her discussion of slavery in Jesus’ parables, see chapter 4, “Parabolic Bodies: The Figure of the Slave in the Sayings of Jesus,” 102–129. For an American example of substantial responsibility exercised by an enslaved person, see Thomas Jefferson Foundation, “Burwell Colbert,” Monticello.

[3] Matthew 25:15, translation notes: the NRSVUE estimates a talent at more than fifteen years’ wages for a laborer; the English Standard Version estimates approximately twenty years’ wages.

[4] Matthew 25:24–25, NRSVUE.

[5] Babylonian Talmud, Bava Metzia 42a, especially sections 6–7 in Sefaria’s numbering, William Davidson Talmud translation. Shmuel teaches: “There is safeguarding for money only in the ground.” N.B., this rabbinic discussion postdates the New Testament period.

[6] Matthew 25:26–30, NRSVUE.

[7] Matthew 25:21, 23, NRSVUE.

[8] Cf. Luke 15:13, King James Version, (“KJV”)

[9] Cf. Matthew 25:18; 5:14–16, NRSVUE. The words translated “hid” in Matthew 25:18 and “hidden” in Matthew 5:14 are forms of the same Greek verb, kryptō, meaning “to hide.”

 

[10] Matthew 18:33, NRSVUE.

[11] Psalm 123:4, The Book of Common Prayer (1979), 780.

[12] Matthew 25:15, NRSVUE.

[13] Adapted from John Buchanan, “High-Risk Venture,” sermon preached at Fourth Presbyterian Church, Chicago, November 17, 2002, https://www.fourthchurch.org/sermons/2002/111702.html. (Accessed November 13, 2026)

[14] Matthew 28:19–20, NRSVUE.